Bill Miller's bakery runs from $1.35 to $3.75 and everything in it is baked on site — unusual for a chain of this size. The fudge brownie portion at $1.35 and 410 kcal is by far the best value in the case at 304 calories per dollar. Pecan pie at $2.75 is the richest item at 550 kcal. Pie slices sit between $2.30 and $2.75, with lemon and coconut meringue cheapest at $2.30. Pecans appear throughout the case, including on shared tongs.
Most chains at this scale buy dessert in. Bill Miller bakes its own, and that decision is expensive enough that it tells you something about the business. It is also the reason this case is worth stopping at rather than walking past.
Because we have published calorie figures for most of it, this is one of the few sections where value can be measured rather than guessed. The answer is emphatic: the $1.35 fudge brownie portion delivers 410 calories, which is 304 calories per dollar — nothing else in the case comes close, and it beats most of the lunch board too. The full ranking across the menu is on our calorie page.
Bakery & Pies — full price list
Every item with its price and, where published, its calorie count. Verified 4 August 2026.
410 kcalPortion Fudge Brownies With PecansSingle brownie portion.$1.35
Slice of Coconut Meringue PieCoconut custard under meringue.$2.30
450 kcalSlice of Lemon PieLemon meringue.$2.30
410 kcalSlice of Apple PieDouble-crust apple.$2.40
Slice of Dutch Apple PieCrumb-topped apple. Same price as regular apple.$2.40
320 kcalLTO Cherry Pie – SliceLimited-time cherry pie. Rotates in and out.$2.40
550 kcalSlice of Pecan PieThe Texas default. Highest-calorie bakery item.$2.75
260 kcal1/2 Dozen Fudge Brownies With PecansSix brownies for the price of 2.8 singles.$3.75| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Portion Fudge Brownies With PecansSingle brownie portion. 410 kcal | $1.35 |
| Slice of Coconut Meringue PieCoconut custard under meringue. | $2.30 |
| Slice of Lemon PieLemon meringue. 450 kcal | $2.30 |
| Slice of Apple PieDouble-crust apple. 410 kcal | $2.40 |
| Slice of Dutch Apple PieCrumb-topped apple. Same price as regular apple. | $2.40 |
| LTO Cherry Pie – SliceLimited-time cherry pie. Rotates in and out. 320 kcal | $2.40 |
| Slice of Pecan PieThe Texas default. Highest-calorie bakery item. 550 kcal | $2.75 |
| 1/2 Dozen Fudge Brownies With PecansSix brownies for the price of 2.8 singles. 260 kcal | $3.75 |
The case ranked by calories per dollar
Computed from Bill Miller's published figures against our verified prices.
| Item | Price | Calories | Calories per $ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Portion Fudge Brownies With Pecans | $1.35 | 410 kcal | 304 — best |
| Slice of Pecan Pie | $2.75 | 550 kcal | 200 |
| Slice of Lemon Pie | $2.30 | 450 kcal | 196 |
| Slice of Apple Pie | $2.40 | 410 kcal | 171 |
| LTO Cherry Pie — Slice | $2.40 | 320 kcal | 133 |
| Slice of Coconut Meringue Pie | $2.30 | — | Not published |
| Slice of Dutch Apple Pie | $2.40 | — | Not published |
| 1/2 Dozen Fudge Brownies With Pecans | $3.75 | 260 kcal each (as published) | See note |
The half-dozen figure of 260 kcal is published per brownie rather than per box, which is inconsistent with the 410 kcal single portion. We are showing it as published rather than reconciling it ourselves — check the official calculator if it matters to you.
Which one to order
On value: the fudge brownie portion at $1.35. Nothing else in the case is close, and it is the cheapest item in the section as well as the densest.
On merit: pecan pie at $2.75. It is the item a national chain cannot replicate — a Texas bakery product baked in the building you are standing in. At 550 kcal it is also the richest thing in the case, so it works better shared after a plate than eaten alone.
After a plate of smoked meat: lemon or coconut meringue at $2.30. Both are sharper and lighter than the pecan, which matters more than it sounds after brisket.
Feeding several people: the half-dozen brownies at $3.75 is the bulk unit here, working out at $0.63 each against $1.35 for a single portion — though the portions differ in size, so it is not a straight comparison.
Nut warning. Pecan pie and both brownie items contain pecans, and they share a case, tongs and surfaces with everything else in it. For a nut allergy this is not a 'choose a different slice' situation — speak to staff. Our allergen guide has the questions worth asking.
Bakery & Pies — questions
How much is a slice of pie at Bill Miller?
Between $2.30 and $2.75. Lemon and coconut meringue are cheapest at $2.30, apple and Dutch apple and the cherry LTO are $2.40, and pecan is $2.75.
What is the best value dessert at Bill Miller?
The fudge brownie portion at $1.35. At 410 calories that is 304 calories per dollar — roughly 50% better than pecan pie and the best figure in the case.
Does Bill Miller bake its own pies?
Yes. Bill Miller runs an on-site bakery, which is unusual for a chain operating 74 stores. It is also why the shared-case allergen picture matters here more than at a chain serving pre-wrapped desserts.
How many calories in Bill Miller pecan pie?
550 kcal for a slice at $2.75 — the highest published figure in the bakery and among the highest on the menu. The full table for all items with published figures is on our calorie page.
Can you buy whole pies at Bill Miller?
The case is built around slices, with brownies by the half dozen. For whole pies or larger quantities — particularly at Thanksgiving — ask your store; it is a catering question rather than a counter one.
Where this page's facts come from
- Bill Miller Bar-B-Q — official site — store list, nutrition calculator, rewards and ordering channels
- Bill Miller Nutrition Calculator — the only first-party calorie tool for this menu
- Bill Miller all-locations list — 74 stores with addresses and phone numbers
Prices marked cross-checked are corroborated against published Bill Miller listings but not yet confirmed from a photographed in-store board. See our verification method.
