Bill Miller's dessert menu is its on-site bakery. It runs to 8 items starting at $1.35: pie by the slice in apple, Dutch apple, pecan, lemon and coconut meringue, fudge brownies with pecans individually or by the half dozen, and a rotating limited-time cherry pie. Everything is baked in store rather than shipped in, which is unusual at this scale. Pecans are present throughout the case, which matters if there is a nut allergy at the table.
Everything in the case, cheapest first
Verified 4 August 2026. Calories shown where Bill Miller publishes them.
| Item | Price | Calories | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Portion Fudge Brownies With Pecans | $1.35 | 410 kcal | Single brownie portion. |
| Slice of Coconut Meringue Pie | $2.30 | — | Coconut custard under meringue. |
| Slice of Lemon Pie | $2.30 | 450 kcal | Lemon meringue. |
| Slice of Apple Pie | $2.40 | 410 kcal | Double-crust apple. |
| Slice of Dutch Apple Pie | $2.40 | — | Crumb-topped apple. Same price as regular apple. |
| LTO Cherry Pie – Slice | $2.40 | 320 kcal | Limited-time cherry pie. Rotates in and out. |
| Slice of Pecan Pie | $2.75 | 550 kcal | The Texas default. Highest-calorie bakery item. |
| 1/2 Dozen Fudge Brownies With Pecans | $3.75 | 260 kcal | Six brownies for the price of 2.8 singles. |
Baked on site. Pecans appear across this case, including on shared tongs and surfaces — see the allergen guide if that matters.
Which one to actually order
Pecan pie, if you are choosing on merit. It is the item on this menu that a national chain genuinely cannot replicate — a Texas bakery product baked in the building you are standing in. It is also the richest thing in the case, so it is a shared-slice proposition rather than an after-a-Rodeo-Plate one.
Fudge brownies with pecans, if you are choosing on value. It is the densest thing in the case for the money, and the half-dozen portion is the sensible unit if you are feeding more than yourself — the same bulk logic that makes family orders work elsewhere on this menu.
Coconut meringue or lemon, if you have just eaten a plate of smoked meat. Both are lighter and sharper than the pecan, which matters more than it sounds after brisket.
Nut warning worth taking seriously. Pecan pie and the fudge brownies both contain pecans, and they share a case, tongs and surfaces with every other item in it. For a nut allergy this is not a "pick a different slice" situation — speak to staff. Our allergen guide covers how to ask.
Questions people actually ask
What desserts does Bill Miller have?
The bakery case is the dessert menu: pies by the slice — apple, Dutch apple, pecan, lemon and coconut meringue — plus fudge brownies with pecans and a rotating limited-time cherry pie.
How much is a slice of pie at Bill Miller?
Pie slices run from $1.35 upward. Full pricing for every bakery item is on the bakery page, and every slice has its own page with calories where published.
Does Bill Miller sell whole pies?
The bakery bakes on site and the case is built around slices, with brownies available by the half dozen. For whole pies or larger quantities, particularly at holidays, ask your store — it is a catering-style question rather than a counter one.
What is the best dessert at Bill Miller?
Pecan pie, if you want the thing this chain does that a national chain cannot — it is baked on site and it is a Texas bakery item, not a shipped-in product. If you want the best value, the brownie portion is the densest thing in the case for the money.
Are Bill Miller desserts made in store?
Bill Miller runs its own bakery, which is unusual for a chain this size and is the reason the case is worth stopping at. It is also why the allergen picture matters here: a shared bakery case means pecan-containing items sit alongside everything else.
Where this page's facts come from
- Bill Miller Bar-B-Q — official site — store list, nutrition calculator, rewards and ordering channels
- Bill Miller Nutrition Calculator — the only first-party calorie tool for this menu
- Bill Miller all-locations list — 74 stores with addresses and phone numbers
Prices marked cross-checked are corroborated against published Bill Miller listings but not yet confirmed from a photographed in-store board. See our verification method.